Josie Birnmham has built a new life for herself and partner Caleb in New York, far away from her disaster of a family in the midwest. To make her life easier, she’s kept a few details of her life from Caleb. he knows nothing about her father’s murder, her mother’s membership in a cult, or her sister Lanie. But a reporter with a podcast about Josie’s father’s unsolved murder is about to change all that. Josie’s carefully constructed life begins to fall apart and when her mother dies, she has to travel home to confront her sister and the lies and secrets that have kept them apart.